Strategy Stock Falls 23% as Peter Schiff Criticizes Saylor's Bitcoin Model

iconCoinpaper
Share
AI summary iconSummary

Bitcoin news broke as Strategy stock (NASDAQ: MSTR) fell nearly 23% in a week, closing at $86.13 on November 19. Peter Schiff, a well-known Bitcoin critic, accused Michael Saylor’s firm of being a “complete fraud.” The stock dropped from $111.62 on November 13 to $86.13 by week’s end, with more losses in premarket trading. Schiff questioned the company’s Bitcoin treasury model, though no evidence of financial fraud was presented. Bitcoin analysis shows the market remains sensitive to high-profile criticism.

Key takeaways

  • Strategy stock loses nearly 23% in one week
  • Peter Schiff renews fraud allegations against Saylor's Bitcoin model
  • Falling Bitcoin prices increase pressure on Strategy's financing strategy

Strategy stock (NASDAQ: MSTR) has crashed nearly 23% in one week, falling to $86.13 by Thursday's close, as prominent Bitcoin critic Peter Schiff renewed his attack on Michael Saylor's company, calling its business model a "complete fraud."

 

Shares dropped from $111.62 on November 13 to $86.13 on November 19, a decline of approximately 22.8%. MSTR extended its weakness into Friday's premarket session, trading around $84.41, or another 2% below Thursday's closing price.

Schiff made his latest remarks on November 20 in response to Saylor's investor Q&A, arguing that Strategy lacks a viable underlying business. The accusations continue his longstanding criticism of the company's Bitcoin treasury model, although his claims do not constitute evidence of financial fraud.

 

Peter Schiff Attacks Strategy as MSTR Stock Collapses

Schiff's latest criticism comes as Bitcoin trades near $61,000, placing additional pressure on companies holding significant cryptocurrency reserves.

Strategy operates primarily as a Bitcoin treasury company, raising capital through common stock, preferred securities and debt instruments to acquire and manage its cryptocurrency holdings.

Critics argue that this structure becomes increasingly vulnerable when Bitcoin declines and the company's equity valuation approaches or falls below the value of its underlying assets.

Schiff has repeatedly questioned the sustainability of Strategy's financing arrangements, previously describing the model as a potential financial death spiral.

The immediate concern involves Strategy's market-adjusted net asset value, or mNAV, which compares its stock-market valuation with the value of its Bitcoin exposure after accounting for relevant capital-structure assumptions.

When MSTR trades at a substantial premium to its underlying Bitcoin holdings, issuing shares can help finance additional purchases. A shrinking premium, however, makes that strategy less attractive and may increase dilution risks.

Strategy Spends More on Preferred Shares Than Bitcoin

The stock decline coincides with a notable change in Strategy's capital allocation.

 

On November 16, the company disclosed purchases of 485 Bitcoin for approximately $33.4 million alongside $228.1 million in repurchases of STRC preferred shares. The transactions followed an earlier period when preferred-stock buybacks also exceeded Bitcoin acquisitions.

The latest capital allocation figures highlight a growing emphasis on managing outstanding securities alongside accumulating cryptocurrency.

According to Strategy's third-quarter financial results, the company held approximately 848,517 BTC as of October 25, with an average acquisition cost near $75,446 per Bitcoin.

At a hypothetical Bitcoin price of $61,000, that reported position would be worth approximately $51.8 billion, roughly $12.2 billion below its original acquisition cost. The calculation is illustrative and does not represent an updated company-reported valuation.

Strategy also reported a $4.83 billion dollar reserve at the end of October to support preferred dividends and debt interest, demonstrating its efforts to manage financial obligations during market volatility.

Can MSTR Stock Recover Above $100?

Strategy's shares now face a significant psychological test as they approach the $80 level.

A recovery above $90 could bring the $100 threshold back into focus, while sustained weakness below $80 would suggest continued pressure on the company's market valuation. These levels represent conditional price scenarios rather than guaranteed technical outcomes.

Investors must also consider Strategy's potential MSCI index exclusion, which could reduce demand from passive investment funds independently of Bitcoin's performance.

 

Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information. Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.