New Jersey Revokes 2023 Staking Order Against Coinbase

iconFLASH AI
Share
AI summary iconSummary
New Jersey revoked its 2023 cease-and-desist order against Coinbase’s staking service, canceling the $5 million penalty. The Bureau of Securities withdrew the action without prejudice, ending a three-year dispute that cost users $15 million in missed rewards. Coinbase’s Q3 report noted the revocation, though New Jersey users still can’t stake new principal. CEO Brian Armstrong said access would return “very soon.” The original case was part of a multi-state challenge over unregistered securities, led by California. The SEC dropped its 2023 staking lawsuit in February 2025. New Jersey is the sixth state to rescind its action, leaving the legal battle unresolved. Meanwhile, BTC remains a key hedge against inflation, and CFT regulations continue to shape the evolving crypto landscape.

New Jersey's Bureau of Securities has revoked the cease-and-desist order imposed on Coinbase's staking service in 2023 and canceled the accompanying $5 million penalty. The withdrawal ends a three-year dispute that cost residents an estimated $15 million in missed staking rewards. Acting Bureau Chief Keith A. Alt signed the withdrawal notice, which bears an October 30 date. The bureau withdrew the action without prejudice and issued no ruling on the merits.

Coinbase's third-quarter report filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission says the bureau communicated an intention to rescind the order on October 29. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong said New Jersey users would regain staking access "very soon." However, Coinbase's eligibility page still excluded New Jersey customers from staking new principal on Monday, and no reopening date has been announced. Coinbase's filing presents the rescission as planned rather than completed, explaining the difference between Armstrong's announcement and the unchanged eligibility page. New Jersey residents will regain access when Coinbase changes the exchange's systems, rather than from the date the notice was signed.

The original New Jersey action began on June 6, 2023, as part of a coordinated challenge to Coinbase's staking program. Securities regulators in Alabama, California, Illinois, Kentucky, Maryland, South Carolina, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin also participated. The states alleged that Coinbase offered unregistered securities through the staking service in violation of state law. California headed the task force, and California's action encompassed more than 600,000 accounts. Coinbase agreed in July 2023 to prevent customers in California, New Jersey, South Carolina and Wisconsin from staking additional funds until final adjudication. Maryland secured a comparable agreement in October 2023. Customers with funds already staked continued receiving rewards but could neither increase principal nor compound those rewards.

The SEC separately sued Coinbase in June 2023, including claims concerning staking. The SEC dismissed the lawsuit in February 2025. Alabama, Kentucky, Illinois, South Carolina and Vermont ended their actions through dismissals, withdrawals or vacaturs during March and April 2025. New Jersey becomes the sixth state among the original ten to retreat from the coordinated action.

The rescission removes New Jersey's restriction on new staking but leaves the underlying legal issue unresolved. The bureau did not determine whether Coinbase's staking program constitutes a security. The withdrawal without prejudice allows the bureau to bring another action. Coinbase's filing characterizes the state proceedings as "preliminary" and warns that an unfavorable outcome could materially affect Coinbase's business.

Coinbase has argued that the state restrictions put the exchange at a competitive disadvantage. Coinbase's Ryan VanGrack argued in an April 2025 post that the orders targeted a single provider even though residents could use other staking platforms. Coinbase estimated that customers across the four restricted states had missed more than $130 million in rewards as of October 2025. California, Maryland and Wisconsin still prohibit new staking through Coinbase while the state cases continue. Washington allows staking but continues to seek a $4 million fine. Coinbase estimates that California residents have missed more than $89 million in rewards since 2023.

Federal policy has changed without reaching a settled position. The SEC has retreated from the registration-based enforcement cases launched in 2023. The House passed the CLARITY market structure bill in 2025, but the legislation stalled in the Senate. State securities regulators need not follow the SEC's enforcement priorities, allowing the staking proceedings to continue more than a year and a half beyond the federal case. A future SEC or a future New Jersey bureau chief could reconsider the legal issue.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information. Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.