According to the Zhitong Financial News app, MSCI, a leading index provider, has completed its first review under new guidelines and officially removed Strategy (MSTR.US) from its indices. This marks the first actual implementation of MSCI’s new framework targeting so-called “non-operating companies”—defined by MSCI as companies whose value primarily stems from held assets rather than operational business. In the same batch, Japan’s Metaplanet and Upexi were also confirmed for removal, while the Ethereum treasury company Sharplink was placed on watchlist.
After the announcement, Strategy's stock price fell nearly 4% during after-hours trading in the U.S. markets. On Stocktwits, retail investor sentiment toward the stock improved from "extremely bearish" to "bearish," and discussion volume rose from "low" to "normal."
How the new rules work: Two-step screening and five tests
MSCI formally adopted this framework in mid-October. The screening process consists of two steps: First, assess whether a company possesses sufficient operating assets; companies that pass are retained directly, while those that fail proceed to the second step—a test of five financial ratios. If a company triggers any four of these ratios, it is classified as a non-operating company and loses its index eligibility.
The five tests are: operating assets account for less than 20% of total assets; operating expenses account for less than 5% of total assets; operating cash flow is negative; fair value changes in non-operating assets exceed 5% of total assets; dependence on financing exceeds 20%.
For companies like Strategy, this set of criteria is almost tailor-made as a barrier—Bitcoin is their absolute primary asset, while their software business is relatively small, making it easy to trigger multiple metrics simultaneously. MSCI has also included a buffer clause: reclassification is triggered only if there is a “sustained change in business structure”; isolated or temporary failures to meet criteria do not constitute grounds for removal. However, the watchlist mechanism limits this buffer—companies that fail to meet the criteria for two consecutive annual reviews will be removed; similarly, cryptocurrency treasury companies outside the index must meet the criteria in at least one of the last two reviews to be eligible for inclusion.
Rule Evolution: From the "50% Threshold" to the "Five Tests"
This round of exclusions is not a sudden move, but the result of MSCI’s rule evolution over the past year. In October 2025, MSCI first proposed excluding companies where digital assets account for more than 50% of total assets, and during the consultation period, imposed temporary restrictions on companies like Metaplanet—halting increases in the number of shares included in the index, blocking new entries, and delaying adjustments to their size classification. At the time, J.P. Morgan estimated that the exclusion of Strategy alone could trigger approximately $2.8 billion in passive fund outflows.
In January this year, MSCI took a step back: it announced it would temporarily not exclude treasury companies based on the 50% digital asset threshold, instead launching a broader consultation—expanding the question from “How to treat crypto treasury companies” to “How to classify companies that primarily hold investments rather than operate businesses.” In August, MSCI proposed a financial test and conducted a simulation using data from May 2026: Strategy, Metaplanet, and uranium investment company Yellow.
Cake has been marked for delisting, while Sharplink and others have been added to the watchlist. The new rules were approved on October 15 and will take effect after market close on November 30; the final list was published on November 11—this round’s implementation.
It is worth noting the spillover effect of the rule: Yellow on the simulated list.
Cake was not included in the final exclusion list; instead, Upexi was added—indicating that the new rules are not limited solely to Bitcoin treasury companies, but also extend to “holding-type companies” outside of crypto. In fact, since January this year, MSCI has deliberately downplayed the “crypto” label, reframing the issue as a neutral classification of “non-operating companies”—meaning gold, commodities, or any company primarily engaged in asset holding could theoretically be subject to the same criteria. This transforms the impact of the new rules beyond the crypto narrative, establishing a precedent for how index construction rules should treat “asset-holding public companies.”
What does it mean to hold a cryptocurrency position?
This is a structural turning point for the entire “Treasury Company” sector. Strategy’s response represents the stance of this camp: “Digital assets are assets. Index providers should measure the market, not decide what assets companies can hold.” The company insists it is a properly functioning business with software operations, financial activities, and credit instruments collateralized by Bitcoin, and criticizes MSCI’s methodology as “arbitrary.”
However, the market-level impact is real: passive funds and ETFs tracking the MSCI index are required to sell stocks removed from the index according to their rules. Although the previous estimate of $2.8 billion in outflows was based on the old 50% threshold criterion, the transmission mechanism remains valid under the new rules. Smaller treasury firms face greater pressure—Metaplanet’s free-float market capitalization in the May simulation was approximately $654 million, meaning the relative impact of passive fund exits on its liquidity is far greater than for Strategy.
The watchlist mechanism also imposes a second wave of pressure: Sharplink has already missed one annual review; if it fails again next time, it will become the next case to be removed. For crypto treasury companies currently outside the index, the new rules effectively close the entry window for the coming months. From a funding perspective, being excluded from the index means these companies lose a key source of passive demand, potentially creating a gap in the core business flywheel of their “issue stock to buy crypto” model—where rising stock prices support additional issuances, which in turn fund further purchases.
Potential impact on Bitcoin
The most important point to understand about the impact on Bitcoin is that the index rules do not force any company to sell Bitcoin—the shares being sold are stocks. The Bitcoin held by Strategy will not automatically enter the market due to index adjustments.
The real chain of transmission is another one. Strategy
The coin-buying model is as follows: when the stock price exceeds its Bitcoin net asset value, the company issues common or preferred shares and uses the raised funds to purchase coins. The premium serves as fuel for this flywheel, while passive buying pressure from index inclusion helps sustain the premium. Once passive funds exit, the demand base for the stock weakens, further pressuring the premium (which is already at a discount), leading to higher financing costs for the company and reduced issuance volumes, thereby shrinking future coin purchases.
Analysts from the decentralized infrastructure network ZEROBASE have issued a warning from this perspective: the loss of index-driven demand could cut off the very issuance that funds coin purchases.
The real risks are not in front of us, but in two areas:
First, there is spillover at the model level. In 2025, individual investors net sold approximately 696,000 bitcoins, while corporations, investment funds, and governments collectively bought nearly 1 million.
Ten thousand coins—enterprise treasuries are one of the most prominent marginal buyer groups in this market. If the category of "digital asset treasuries" is collectively excluded by mainstream index systems, Metaplanet, Upexi
Smaller companies of this type may face a more severe demand shock, and the overall buying pressure across the entire group could contract, not just from Strategy alone.
Second, whether other index providers will follow suit. TFTC has previously analyzed FTSE Russell and S&P Dow Jones Indices.
Jones) follow-up scenario, but as of publication, neither company has announced any related consultations. This represents the greatest tail risk to the token price—the moment the rule spreads from one index provider to the entire index system, what is constrained will no longer be just one company’s fundraising ability, but an entire channel of asset allocation.


