Key points
- MSCI confirms the removal of Strategy from its major stock indices.
- The volume of sell orders for passive funds could reach billions of dollars.
- Bitcoin reserve companies face stricter institutional investment restrictions.
Michael Saylor’s Strategy (NASDAQ: MSTR) may face billions of dollars in passive fund selling after MSCI confirmed it will remove the bitcoin reserve company from its global stock index, ending months of uncertainty over its eligibility for inclusion.
The MSCI index review results as of November 11 show that Strategy's Class A common stock has been added to the list of stocks to be removed from the MSCI USA Index. The related adjustment will take effect after the close of trading on November 30, meaning that investment portfolios tracking this index will need to adjust their holdings.
MSCI's removal could trigger $2.8 billion in selling pressure on Strategy stocks.
JPMorgan Chase previously estimated that Strategy's removal from the MSCI benchmark index could lead to approximately $2.8 billion in stock outflows, as passive investors need to rebalance their portfolios.
A broader scenario estimate suggests that if other major index providers adopt similar exclusion measures, the selling pressure could reach $8.8 billion.
However, neither of these figures represents confirmed transactions, and the larger figure should not be attributed solely to MSCI’s decision.
For months prior to this move, the market has been debating whether companies holding large cryptocurrency reserves should be considered traditional operating businesses.
MSCI initially considered imposing restrictions on digital asset reserve companies, but later introduced broader eligibility criteria for non-operating entities.
According to its final framework, MSCI will evaluate companies based on operating asset criteria and five financial ratios. Existing constituents are typically removed after failing to meet the relevant criteria for two consecutive reporting periods.
This change also brings closure to the prior controversy surrounding the MSCI inclusion eligibility of Strategy and Japan’s Metaplanet.
As stock prices come under pressure, Strategy holds 850,364 bitcoins.
Strategy remains the publicly traded company with the largest Bitcoin holdings, owning a total of 850,364 BTC at an acquisition cost of approximately $64.17 billion.
According to the company's official Bitcoin ledger, its most recent purchase added 1,036 BTC at a cost of approximately $82 million.
At the time of this purchase, the company’s capital allocation strategy also became more complex.
Earlier this week, Strategy disclosed that the company spent $188.3 million to repurchase preferred shares and raised approximately $283.8 million through the issuance of common shares.
The company's recent Bitcoin reserve financing update details this arrangement and illustrates why investor demand for MSTR remains significant.
Potential index-driven selling does not mean Strategy must sell its held Bitcoin. Instead, a decline in the stock price may reduce the company’s future attractiveness for financing.
Strategy previously stated that classifying Bitcoin-reserve companies as investment funds misrepresents the nature of their operating and financing activities.
What does MSCI's decision mean for Bitcoin reserve stocks?
Its impact extends beyond Strategy.
Metaplanet is also among the companies affected by the MSCI November review, and Ethereum reserve company SharpLink is facing additional eligibility review.
This decision presents another challenge to the valuation model of Bitcoin reserve companies, as such models often rely on the company’s stock price trading above the value of its underlying cryptocurrency holdings.
When this premium narrows, the strategy of buying Bitcoin by issuing new shares may become less effective.
During previous market corrections, this relationship has led to an expansion of discounts and a weakening of premium for reserve-type stocks.
In January, MSCI temporarily refrained from excluding cryptocurrency reserve companies, which briefly reassured investors; as a result, the impact of this decision is now even more pronounced.

