After Alphabet (GOOGL) released its earnings report, its stock plummeted on Thursday, while Microsoft (MSFT) remained unaffected—in other words, Microsoft’s stock did not follow Google’s decline. The reason behind this is actually quite simple.
The market views Microsoft’s performance this quarter as exceeding expectations with sustainable high growth; in contrast, Alphabet’s performance this quarter was weak and signaled that its growth rate may slow further in the coming quarters.
Microsoft Azure's sales growth exceeded analyst expectations by approximately 300 basis points. Excluding the impact of currency fluctuations, overall revenue from this core cloud business increased by 48% year-over-year. Management provided a revenue growth guidance for Azure this quarter of 49%–50%, which is 4 percentage points higher than the market consensus forecast.
The company's capital expenditures were approximately $5 billion lower than expected, and revenue from other business segments also exceeded forecasts. Overall revenue and profitability for the quarter both surpassed analyst expectations.
Stifel analyst Brad Reback said: “Overall, this earnings report strengthened our confidence. We believe Microsoft is capable of sustaining mid- to high-double-digit revenue growth; meanwhile, strong gross margins and operational efficiency on the expense side will continue to drive expansion in operating profit margins.”
Microsoft real-time quote: $524.19, down $6.82 (‑1.28%), as of 12:15:39 PM Eastern Time, during regular trading hours.
Alphabet's Q3 earnings report was disappointing, with its performance falling short of expectations and paling in comparison to Microsoft, causing its stock to plunge 12%. The main issues were twofold: First, Google's search revenue amounted to $63.4 billion, below the expected $64.9 billion. The missed revenue target intensified market concerns that, despite massive investments, the foundational dominance of Google's search business is gradually being eroded by AI products like Claude and ChatGPT.
Second, Google's free cash flow was -$9.1 billion, significantly worse than Wall Street's expectation of -$3.5 billion. The market is currently highly sensitive to negative free cash flow among large tech companies (refer to the market's reaction to Meta's earnings last week, where Meta posted negative free cash flow for the first time in years, leading to stock pressure). Google's free cash flow figure has greatly disappointed investors.
Justin Patterson, an analyst at KeyBanc, said: "Alphabet's Q3 earnings confirmed our pre-earnings concerns: search revenue is slowing, and short-term profit margins have peaked. The market may enter a valuation vacuum over the next one to two quarters as investors wait for signals to determine whether this trend represents a short-term fluctuation or a structural, long-term shift."


