Greenhouse Gas Protocol Faces Dispute Over Corporate Influence

iconFLASH AI
Share
AI summary iconSummary
The Greenhouse Gas Protocol faces internal conflict over a protocol update that could shift emissions disclosure rules. CEO Tim Mohin, previously at BCG, has pushed to soften requirements for time- and location-matched clean energy, according to internal documents. Major tech firms like Amazon and Meta support the changes, arguing clean energy investments can offset emissions. Staff and the Ikea Foundation have raised concerns about corporate influence. The Protocol insists its process remains open and free from undue pressure. Meanwhile, cryptocurrency rules remain a separate but growing focus in emissions discussions.

The Greenhouse Gas Protocol's chief executive has sought to prevent tougher rules governing Big Tech's environmental claims, prompting a dispute over corporate influence. Internal documents and interviews with colleagues indicate that Tim Mohin has advocated aligning the standards-setting body more closely with major companies, including Amazon and Meta. Mohin, previously a BCG partner, became the Protocol's first chief executive this year. The EU, California and the International Financial Reporting Standards use the Protocol's standards for corporate emissions disclosures, exposing the body to lobbying from technology, oil and gas companies.

The Protocol proposed stricter disclosure requirements last year and subsequently opened a public consultation. The proposals would require companies to invest in energy generated at approximately the same time and within the same electricity market as the electricity consumed. Google has supported that approach. The central dispute concerns how far major electricity consumers can offset emissions associated with power generated from oil, gas and coal. A revised standard is scheduled for 2028, following six years of consultation. Amazon, Microsoft, Meta and Google have maintained that clean energy investments could effectively neutralize the companies' contribution to global warming as AI data centres consume increasing amounts of energy.

Staff members say Mohin complained before becoming chief executive that scientists and technical experts within the Protocol were biased against companies. People familiar with an intervention said Mohin subsequently asked staff to consider changes that would weaken the proposed standards. Those people said Mohin cited concerns raised by corporate members of the Protocol's Independent Standards Board. The people said Mohin then planned to meet representatives primarily drawn from large consumer and technology companies, including Amazon and Google, about shared concerns over the proposals. Senior staff persuaded Mohin not to attend because specialist colleagues would be absent and the attendance could suggest openness to private lobbying. One staff member described concern that Mohin was acting independently of colleagues, while another adviser said transparency and the manner of meetings were the issues. Published minutes show that an Amazon representative attended a Protocol donor gathering with Mohin a few days after the planned meeting date.

People familiar with the process said Mohin designed a governance reform programme for the Protocol last year while working as a BCG partner. Mohin helped draft the description for the chief executive job that Mohin later accepted. Mohin argued that the position should be able to shape standards according to corporate perspectives, an approach called a "market acceptance criterion". The nonprofit World Resources Institute and World Business Council for Sustainable Development established the Protocol to provide coordinated standards. The Protocol said those organisations ultimately decided the governance arrangements and chief executive job description. The Protocol said Mohin's consulting supported work that the body's leadership had commissioned and directed.

An external review commissioned by the Ikea Foundation, one of the Protocol's largest funders, warned last month about extensive corporate representation on two governing committees. The review said that representation threatened the Protocol's "independence and credibility". People familiar with two letters said Pankaj Bhatia, then the Protocol's global director with 20 years of service, warned senior management in April and May about the risk of corporate capture. The second letter described Bhatia's perception that the leadership was seeking to diminish scientific and expert findings. The second letter also raised concerns about growing dependence on BCG and conflicts of interest involving Mohin's proposed governance changes. Colleagues and advisers who worked with Mohin said those colleagues and advisers shared Bhatia's concerns. Bhatia has since retired.

The Protocol said scientists, technical experts, civil society, governments and businesses participate in a transparent process to develop standards. The Protocol said scientific integrity, transparency, independence and inclusive decisions underpin that process. Mohin said the Protocol's governance arrangements do not permit the chief executive to vote on new standards. Mohin said leaders entering newly established positions have a duty to listen carefully to all stakeholders. The Protocol said Mohin had met environmental and advocacy organisations, industry groups, companies and other stakeholders since becoming chief executive. The Protocol said no stakeholder could exert undue influence over outcomes.

The Protocol receives funding from Deloitte, EY, KPMG, Apple, Google, Meta and Microsoft. The Protocol is considering becoming a separate legal entity. Google and Meta did not answer requests for comment. Amazon, Microsoft and BCG declined to comment.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information. Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.