Compound Partner Analyzes Four Stages of Tech Narrative Cycles for Startups

iconTechFlow
Share
AI summary iconSummary
Market news highlights a new framework from Compound managing partner Michael Dempsey, who outlined four stages of the tech narrative cycle for startups: the Obscurity Phase, the Wave of Rising Conviction & Consensus, Peak Fervor & Euphoria, and Rise from the Ashes. Each stage requires tailored communication and positioning. Bitcoin market news often reflects compressed hype cycles, where timing and execution are critical to building cognitive moats in competitive markets.

Author: Michael Dempsey, Managing Partner at Compound

Compiled by Deep潮 TechFlow

Shenchao Summary: In the technology and venture capital markets, the technology hype cycle is rapidly compressing, shrinking from the previous 48 months to just 12 to 36 months. The timing at which startups choose to enter the narrative cycle upon their public debut has evolved from a public relations embellishment into a first-order strategic decision critical to their survival.

Compound managing partner Michael Dempsey breaks down the four evolutionary stages of the narrative cycle: obscurity, rising consensus, frenzy and euphoria, and rebirth from the ashes. Each stage operates under fundamentally different laws of offense and defense; blindly applying generic templates only turns companies into casualties amid the noise.

Whether defining categories in the early stage, deconstructing micro-narratives in the middle phase, or competing for differentiation and distribution at the peak, top teams treat narrative building as a core infrastructure as vital as product development. Only by understanding which phase of the cycle you’re in can you firmly build a moat of perception amid pressure from capital and competitors.

When a startup officially announces its launch to the public, the founder must clearly understand where their specific赛道 currently stands within the narrative cycle. At Compound Ventures, we consistently believe this task requires meticulous refinement, careful consideration, and strategic intent—making it a core focus we regularly refine with our portfolio teams.

From the perspective of a simplified model, the technology narrative cycle is typically divided into four progressive stages:

First, the Obscurity Phase. At this extremely early stage, external attention is minimal, with only a tiny core group paying attention, and almost no direct competition exists. This means founders must take on the responsibility of market education, anticipating and shaping narratives before industry certainty is established.

Second, the wave of rising conviction and consensus. In this mid-stage evolution, hype intensifies gradually as multiple competitors enter the space and collectively elevate related narratives. Top talent and investment institutions are swiftly transitioning from curious onlookers to staunch believers.

Third, peak fervor and euphoria. In the late stage, enthusiasm, industry consensus, and competitive density reach their zenith, causing product differentiation to become significantly more difficult, capital to become markedly excessive, and a large number of speculative followers to flood in.

Fourth, rising from the ashes. After the collapse following its peak, market expectations are completely reset; former enthusiastic supporters become skeptics, and media, talent, and the investment community often express highly negative sentiments regarding the commercial viability of this technology or sector.

These stages are interconnected and progressively build upon one another. At each stage, the team must employ distinctly different methodologies and communication strategies to effectively enter the market and establish meaningful dialogue amid varying intensities and types of external noise.

Quiet phase (early stage)

The obscure phase of the narrative cycle encompasses a broad range of possibilities, but it is often the fertile ground where miracles are born—where an entirely new category can be defined from scratch, or where the boundaries of what is technologically possible are significantly expanded.

Under today’s startup pace, this stage typically lasts 12 to 36 months, with the first 12 months often progressing in near-total silence, well below the radar of the market.

The key advantage of making a public debut at the outset of a narrative cycle is that you can establish a moat of ideas at a macro level and secure narrative dominance within the category. This was true in the early days of NewSpace, GovTech, deep learning, and synthetic biology.

By securing this first-mover advantage, companies gain considerable flexibility in their public relations and marketing narratives. The team can initially tell stories centered around broad, widely relatable visions, and over time gradually narrow the focus to specific product details or feature highlights that matter only to professional buyers and core insiders.

Another key advantage is that, before the market descends into cutthroat competition, the competition for talent driven by mission or specialized industry expertise remains relatively mild. At that time, job seekers are more willing to embrace the broader goal of space exploration without insisting on specific roles such as satellite communications or in-orbit manufacturing.

Finally, early leaders with strong execution can continuously attract capital as the narrative gains momentum, rapidly ascending to become the Schelling Point company or category leader amid institutional competition to elevate them.

However, prematurely entering a specific narrative cycle also carries significant risks and challenges.

Entering the market too early often exposes companies to the risks of being copied or outperformed by later entrants with stronger execution, even turning them into public case studies for fast followers. With startups typically facing 2 to 4 venture-backed competitors within 24 months of founding, this phenomenon is becoming increasingly common.

Companies in their obscurity phase often struggle to build a sufficiently large commercial moat in time. As the potential customer base expands, while pioneers secure the early ecosystem, later entrants can leverage existing lessons to precisely target a single core pain point, capturing new customers and scaling up.

Overall, because you entered too early, you likely raced ahead before the outcome was settled. Any significant shift at the foundational level of an industry may force you to change course and rebuild your narrative. Early AI wrapper applications once became deeply stuck in this trap, severely underestimating the impact of rapid advancements in cutting-edge large models and labs launching their own in-house developments.

Similar dilemmas have also arisen in sectors such as robotics infrastructure, commercial aerospace software, and contract synthetic biology manufacturing, where commercialization has slowed. These industries implicitly bet that industry scaling would outpace reality, ultimately becoming passive due to their inability to validate their business flywheels every 18 to 36 months as venture capital expectations demand.

Rising conviction and the wave of consensus formation

In startups and the tech market, narratives always surge in waves. As categories solidify, companies either succeed in becoming the central Schelling point of the macro-category or must fiercely compete for dominance within the category’s micro-narratives.

Waves of rising conviction often have longer evolution curves. During this stage, you not only see early leaders scaling up, but also witness a flood of fast-following startups that secured early funding, giving rise to the first signs of narrative fatigue.

These follow-up companies typically cling to the same narrative anchors, often operated by teams with impressive pedigrees, attempting to leapfrog competitors by raising massive amounts of capital. This phenomenon stems from venture capital firms blindly copying successful examples, mistakenly believing that deploying larger sums of money will automatically accelerate progress—though the reality is often quite different.

After being bombarded with the same macro concepts for 24 consecutive months, the public, investors, potential employees, and customers often experience aesthetic fatigue and skepticism. The entire industry quickly transforms from an imaginative blue ocean into a crowded, fiercely competitive red ocean.

I previously analyzed this typical dynamic when Inflection attempted to challenge leading AI labs, in an article examining open-source AI business models and brand moats:

For this reason, most founders launching their companies midway through the wave are forced to articulate a more precise and distinctive core belief—or convincingly demonstrate why a narrower, more focused micro-narrative holds commercial value equal to or even greater than the broad narratives once dominated by early leaders.

Learn from precedent: After SpaceX established its leadership in the aerospace industry (2010–2016), the commercial aerospace sector rapidly diversified into highly specialized sub-sectors such as satellite data platforms, rocket launches, in-orbit manufacturing, and space communications—mirroring this same pattern of segmentation across many cutting-edge technology sectors.

The advantage of entering during the mid-stage of the wave is that, if you can clearly communicate your unique value proposition, you gain more time to understand industry patterns and benefit from the market cultivation efforts of early pioneers. However, this also means your burden of proof increases significantly—you must rigorously demonstrate why your solution is superior and more worthy of attention.

For founders at this stage, the most practical strategy is to leverage the insider perspectives of their own investors or former employees of early benchmark companies to analyze why previous pioneers resonated with the public, customers, capital, and talent—and at which critical junctures they unfortunately lost focus.

As the middle phase of the narrative cycle moves toward its climax, the narrative positioning itself becomes a wave that must be ridden and aligned with.

The top 5 to 10 players in a specific niche typically quickly realize that, if they cannot become the Schelling point company for the entire category, they must progressively deconstruct the macro-narrative and anchor themselves in more specific use cases. This incremental path, as illustrated below, involves descending step by step down the category pyramid to reach core products and applications:

The specific trajectory is evident: a group of companies initially adopted the broad banner of climate technology, then narrowed their focus to next-generation clean energy, further delved into the nuclear energy sector, and ultimately pinpointed small modular reactors (SMRs), building their worldview narrative around concrete engineering breakthroughs.

A similar evolution is evident in the American Dynamism theme, where the narrative has gradually shifted from macro-level strategy to defense technology, next-generation military hardware, and ultimately to the specific development of hypersonic missiles.

If this field has already demonstrated strong and growing commercial willingness to pay, companies can bypass intermediate stages entirely and directly target highly specialized, easily understandable use cases, such as AI tailored for legal or financial verticals.

The mid-cycle phase is the most challenging to trade because the early and late stages of the mid-cycle feel fundamentally different. Determining when and at what pace a company should execute this narrative descent is an extremely rigorous博弈. As the time a sector remains in the public spotlight extends, the bar for proving business effectiveness will only rise higher.

We observe that the top teams are often able to consistently maintain high-frequency market presence within their niche over the long term, thereby establishing themselves as the primary owners of the core assets within that ideological moat. This is no easy feat—it requires teams to prioritize external market communication as a top-tier focus in both ideology and organizational resource allocation.

Climax of frenzy and heightened emotion

When the热度 and consensus around a particular sector reach their peak, a wave of slower-moving followers emerges, while numerous previously unrelated companies also rush to pivot and attempt to hitch a ride on the trending concept.

Looking back at the 2021 crypto wave, many traditional businesses hastily slapped on a blockchain label and rushed into the market, amid widespread hype and noise.

This scene replayed in 2023 to 2024: numerous startups secured massive funding fueled by the popularity of diffusion models and the momentum of Midjourney and Runway, launching a wave of so-called creative AI applications that briefly dominated social media before fading into obscurity.

The code generation space in 2025 is also destined to follow this path. Companies have rushed to cover the full spectrum—from enhanced IDE tools to fully autonomous code agents and no-code app generation—resulting in a surge of highly similar, copycat funding projects over the past 12 to 24 months.

Although entrants in each case strive to distinguish themselves by highlighting a specific feature or niche vertical at launch, any rational and clear-eyed observer would form an underlying expectation: the vast majority of these companies will ultimately converge into high homogeneity and fierce consolidation.

To successfully rise to the peak of a narrative cycle’s frenzy, you must either hold a truly transformative product that cuts through the noise or possess a large-scale distribution channel that ensures victory in battle. At the same time, massive market spending must be tightly aligned with high-frequency delivery to prevent the narrative from becoming an unsubstantiated castle in the air.

Entering at the peak of euphoria still offers, objectively, a tactical possibility of precisely aligning with narrative gaps and unoccupied real-world dimensions, but this heavily depends on extremely meticulous dissemination planning and solid execution. Although it appears to be the worst timing to enter, for teams well-versed in narrative leverage or skilled in strong counter-positioning, it can instead allow them to secure a foothold among specific believers.

However, the greatest fatal flaw of entering at the peak is that it often results in a compromised late-to-market launch or becoming a mediocre follower with no competitive moat, failing to generate any lasting impact among real users from the very beginning.

Reborn from the ashes

The tech industry has always been exceptionally skilled at making excessive short-term promises that fall short in delivery, often triggering intense emotional disillusionment and causing a hard reset of hype and trust across the entire market for specific categories. This is the most grueling moment for founders, but if history repeats itself, a few phoenixes rising from the ashes will find tremendous opportunities here.

It must be acknowledged that initiating a project amid ruins is rarely a deliberate choice, but rather an objective reality following the collapse of what came before, or a near-obsessive faith held by the founding team in the face of complete uncertainty. Even from a highly rational venture capital perspective, this pure determination remains invaluable.

As the agitation, disappointment, and aversion that accompany peak excess gradually subside, the market will once again attract a rational audience eager to be truly inspired, awaiting a renewed worldview around this technology or sector. The most outstanding companies will transform past industry failures into an essential prologue in their own entrepreneurial epic.

Achieving this often sparks a new growth cycle, drives a revaluation of the entire category, and helps companies attract substantial capital again to withstand the next wave of followers, thereby reigniting the narrative flywheel for another spin.

The crypto industry has historically excelled at this, reinventing existing architectures and introducing new speculative and mechanistic paradigms in every cycle; clean energy and climate technology have similarly endured multiple cycles of boom and bust, steadily evolving through the groundwork and reconstruction of countless predecessors.

The most tangible examples today can be found in the fields of biotechnology and computational biology. Computational drug discovery platforms like Recursion continue to fully deliver on their early technological promises after a decade-long journey, while synthetic biology companies such as Ginkgo strive to establish viable business models amid the countless failed ventures in the industry.

For these deeply specialized technological and hard-tech sectors, the entire industry may only need to witness one or two landmark turning points that bridge the gap between promise and reality to completely transform the valuation of the entire asset class and attract massive growth-stage venture capital back into these nearly abandoned deep waters.

The existential questioning of narrative strategy

Over the past decade, Compound has invested significant effort into systematically exploring how narratives spread and permeate between technological breakthroughs, elite talent networks, core customers, and financial capital. A decade ago, carefully crafted narratives were perhaps seen as a soft advantage—an added bonus; today, mastering the timing of narratives has become a first-order strategic pillar, on par with product development and channel expansion.

The technology hype cycle has been drastically compressed from 48 months to 12 to 36 months, leaving founders with significantly less room for trial and error. Whether defining a new category in obscurity, precisely cultivating micro-narratives as consensus builds, breaking through at the peak of enthusiasm through high-frequency delivery, or rebuilding industry trust from the ashes, business success increasingly depends on whether your narrative aligns precisely with the physical laws of the current cycle.

Truly competitive leading companies have long integrated narrative building as an integral part of their top-level strategy, not merely as a public relations afterthought following product-market fit (PMF). In a brutal market where competitors rise with massive capital at lightning speed, securing dominant mental positioning through high-level narratives has evolved from a marginal advantage into an existential imperative for corporate survival.

Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information. Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.