Analysts at global investment banks warn that state purchases cannot generate a lasting rally in China's stock market, the world's second-largest. State investors known as the "national team" bought as much as 170 billion yuan (US$25.5 billion) this month through exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and other investment vehicles. The analysts argued that the intervention sought to limit further stock declines and prevent systemic risk. Increasingly evident state buying helped the benchmark CSI 300 Index gain 0.68% on Wednesday morning.
Macquarie and Swiss private bank Julius Baer said purchases by Central Huijin Investment and other state-backed investors could temporarily stabilise trading. The banks said sustained gains require stronger corporate earnings and domestic demand, which remains weak in China's economy. State intervention accelerated this month after the CSI 300 entered a bear market. The technology-heavy Star 50 index had lost more than 40% from a record high.
Goldman Sachs estimated that state investors probably purchased about 170 billion yuan of ETFs following major stock indexes in October. Bank of America put those purchases at more than 110 billion yuan. Larger trading volumes in the biggest ETFs linked to the CSI 300 and Star 50 suggested state purchases, because state investors primarily use these funds to intervene. The latest intervention concentrated more heavily on technology stocks than the interventions in 2015 and 2024. Technology stocks are central to Beijing's effort to achieve technological self-reliance. Bank of America said ETFs following the Star 50 and Shenzhen's ChiNext index of technology start-ups received about 50 billion yuan in new inflows this month.
Macquarie chief China economist Larry Hu said state investors aim to stabilise stocks and prevent systemic risk. Hu said a lasting rally still requires domestic demand to recover, which may happen when Beijing can no longer depend on exports for growth. Hu said state stock purchases also fit Beijing's countercyclical policy approach. Hu compared the purchases with fiscal policy adjustments designed to meet the annual growth target without large stimulus packages that could push growth beyond that target.
Societe Generale estimated that state investors could have sold 1.5 trillion yuan of holdings during the exuberant market conditions that lasted until June this year. Societe Generale said those sales sought to restrain rapid price increases. Societe Generale said state investors resumed net purchases in July after sentiment weakened. Trading remains volatile as investors alternate between expectations of greater state support and concerns over economic growth and the reversal of crowded artificial intelligence investments.
Julius Baer analyst Richard Tang said stocks historically tended to reach a low one or three months after state interventions. Tang said a substantial rebound would not come until early next year, when policymakers would need to intensify measures to revive economic growth. Tang recommended high-dividend stocks as protection against current market volatility. Bank of America strategist Patrick Pan said the latest measures appear focused on limiting downside risks rather than reversing market declines, and saw little incentive for prolonged intervention because China's stocks are not alone in suffering from the global retreat from artificial intelligence investments and indexes remain substantially above lows reached two to three years ago.
Analysts Warn State Buying Won't Reverse China's Stock Slide
FLASH AIShare
Analysts warn state buying won’t reverse China’s stock slide, as the fear and greed index remains skewed toward fear. State investors, or the "national team," bought up to 170 billion yuan in ETFs this month. Macquarie and Julius Baer say stronger corporate earnings and demand are needed for a real rebound. Goldman Sachs and Bank of America estimated state purchases at 170 billion and over 110 billion yuan, respectively. Recent buying focused on tech stocks, a key area for Beijing’s self-reliance goals. Societe Generale noted state investors sold 1.5 trillion yuan earlier this year. Richard Tang of Julius Baer said a meaningful rebound may not come until early next year. With market sentiment weak, altcoins to watch could gain traction among investors seeking alternatives.
Source:Show original
Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information.
Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.