The structural shift in demand brought about by the AI wave caught Apple off guard.Article author and source: Wall Street Journal
A two-decade-long uneven power struggle between flash memory suppliers and Apple is being quietly overturned by the wave of artificial intelligence. Once able to push suppliers to the brink of loss with massive orders, Apple now faces rising costs, while long-subordinated storage manufacturers finally gain the leverage they need for negotiation.
According to TechInsights, demand from AI hyperscale data centers has driven flash memory prices up fivefold over the past year, with prices per GB rising from approximately 5 cents to over 30 cents. This year, tech giants including Microsoft, Amazon, and Meta have signed long-term supply agreements with Kioxia, securing stable supply in exchange for committed higher prices.
According to The Wall Street Journal, Apple is estimated to spend approximately $25 billion on flash memory this year, compared to only about $6 billion for the same amount of storage in 2025.
Apple's Executive Chairman Tim Cook compared the sharp rise in memory chip prices to a "hundred-year flood," but according to media reports citing informed sources, company executives were completely unprepared—having long believed they understood the market better than anyone else. This summer, at the annual flash memory industry conference in Santa Clara, California, suppliers and their sales teams openly expressed delight in private conversations about Apple's weakening bargaining power.
Twenty Years of Price Suppression: How Apple Controlled the Flash Memory Market
Apple's relationship with the flash memory industry began in 2001 with a meeting that changed the course of the consumer electronics industry. At the time, engineers from Kioxia, then known as Toshiba, showed two Apple executives a 1.8-inch miniature hard drive. Apple promptly secured exclusive rights to the device and incorporated it into the iPod—a product that became a landmark milestone for the company.
In 2005, Apple launched the iPod Nano with flash memory chips and prepaid $1.25 billion to five suppliers to secure supply through 2010. Thereafter, with the advent of the iPhone and the rapid expansion of the market, Apple became the world’s largest buyer of flash memory, accounting for more than one-fifth of global supply and spending $3 to $4 billion annually.
Apple has maximized the bargaining power gained through scale. It mandates that suppliers designate it as their "most favored customer" and regularly audits suppliers' accounts to ensure no competitor receives a lower price. Apple has even used this leverage to gain real-time access to suppliers' factory production capacity data, enabling it to precisely determine the suppliers' bottom line during negotiations.
Apple’s procurement chief, Tony Blevins, is known for his tough negotiation style and nicknamed "Blevinator." One of his common tactics is to refuse timely delivery after securing a low-price order—if market prices continue to fall, Apple can further pressure suppliers to lower prices, forcing them to absorb excess inventory of custom chips. Kioxia executives privately joke about this dynamic, comparing it to "Charlie Brown trying to kick the football," implying that Apple always retracts its promises at the last moment.
The supplier's counterattack and defeat
The supplier did not fail to attempt self-rescue. Around 2015, SanDisk refused to increase its supply to Apple because other customers were willing to pay more. Blevins then threatened to make SanDisk’s CEO, Sanjay Mehrotra, "crawl back on his knees" to Apple.
Around 2017, flash memory supply tightened, and Western Digital (SanDisk’s parent company) required Apple to pay a reservation fee to secure chip supply, without any purchase obligation. Blevins flew into a rage, wrote the date on his office whiteboard and circled it, then sent a photo to Western Digital executive Mike Cordano, vowing retaliation.
When flash memory prices dropped the following year, Cordano and his colleague Jerry Kagele went to Apple’s office to present a refund check as a goodwill gesture. Blevins not only demanded that they promise never to charge reservation fees again but also imposed punitive terms requiring Western Digital to pay for Apple’s chip testing services, with no obligation on Apple’s part to purchase any chips. Following this, the two were escorted out by Apple security personnel.
In 2023, the entire industry hit rock bottom. Demand for devices driven by remote work during the pandemic subsided, and flash memory prices fell to a historic low of five cents per GB. According to Bernstein Research, the flash memory industry incurred operating losses of as much as $19 billion that year, while Apple alone generated approximately $14 billion in gross profit from storage upgrades during the same period.
Apple's profit model and cost pressures
Storage upgrades have long been one of Apple’s most profitable product lines. According to an analysis by The Wall Street Journal, from the initial launch of the iPhone and iPad through 2025, Apple has earned an average gross profit of more than 80 cents for every dollar collected in storage upgrade fees; this margin is also close to 80 cents for Mac products.
Using the iPhone 17 Pro, released in 2025, as an example, consumers paid $200 to upgrade storage from 256GB to 512GB, while Apple’s storage cost at the time was only about $15, yielding a gross profit of $185. According to analysis by The Wall Street Journal, the cost of the same storage upgrade for the iPhone 18 Pro has surged to $66, reducing Apple’s gross profit to $134. For the 1TB upgrade option, costs jumped from $42 to $192, and Apple raised the consumer price from $400 to $600. In 2026, Apple introduced a 2TB option for the first time on the iPhone 18 Pro, priced at $1,200, with an associated storage cost of approximately $450.
According to IDC, approximately 100 million iPhone users purchased storage upgrades last year, generating over $10 billion in gross profit for Apple alone, based on an average gross margin of 85%. With costs now rising sharply, Apple has increased prices across nearly its entire product lineup. The average price of the iPhone has risen by 13%, the 13-inch iPad Air has seen price increases of $150 to $250 across storage variants, and the 14-inch MacBook Pro has seen price hikes of $200 to $400 across configurations.
The market landscape is being reshaped, with both parties facing uncertainty.
The structural shift in demand brought about by the AI wave caught Apple off guard. According to media reports citing insiders, Apple’s internal executives believed their judgment of the flash memory market surpassed that of any external analyst and failed to respond promptly to warning signs. Flash memory prices dropped from $68 per GB in 2005 to five cents per GB in 2023, and nearly two decades of one-way decline reinforced this confidence—yet left Apple unprepared when prices reversed.
Large-scale cloud providers can accept higher prices because flash storage represents a relatively small portion of data center construction costs, and accounting standards allow companies to amortize these costs over multiple years. This stands in stark contrast to Apple’s cost sensitivity in consumer hardware.
For Apple, the key uncertainty right now is whether consumers can absorb continuously rising prices—will users delay upgrades or reduce purchases in the face of more expensive storage upgrades? For flash memory suppliers, the question is whether Apple can regain negotiating leverage once market conditions change.
Walt Coon, analyst at TechInsights, said:
Apple has historically held a strong position in negotiations with storage suppliers. Now, as the balance of power shifts, there is indeed a genuine sense of satisfaction among the suppliers.

