Aave risk adviser LlamaRisk proposed stopping new osETH deposits and new borrowing against osETH on Aave's V3 Core market on November 10. StakeWise founder Dmitri asked Aave governance on November 11 to consider the osETH freeze in a separate vote. Dmitri sought time for StakeWise to address concerns before another assessment. The proposed freeze would leave existing positions open.
LlamaRisk's November 9 analysis valued osETH collateral at $279.4 million, supporting an estimated $256.6 million of Wrapped Ethereum (WETH) debt. LlamaRisk allocated the debt proportionally according to each borrower's mix of collateral. LlamaRisk estimated leverage at around 14 times within Aave's ETH-correlated efficiency mode (E-Mode), where osETH's loan-to-value limit was 93%. The 10 largest positions represented 66% of the attributed debt. That concentration makes the handling of existing positions important to the transition.
Independent daily reserve snapshots recorded deposits of 122,900 osETH on November 9. The snapshots recorded deposits of 122,400 osETH on November 11. Aavescan showed an osETH loan balance of 0.0074 osETH on both dates. That balance measures loans of osETH rather than WETH debt secured by osETH, so the figures do not conflict.
LlamaRisk argues that V3's common lending pool exposes WETH and stablecoin suppliers to collateral risks while charging a pooled borrowing rate. LlamaRisk says borrowers capture the additional spread through looping strategies that enlarge staking positions with borrowed funds. Dmitri said StakeWise had suffered neither hacks nor validator slashings since January 2021. Dmitri also described immutable native leverage contracts that return borrowed ETH directly from validators. A separate vote would allow governance to assess Dmitri's argument against Aave's lending-risk criteria.
The initial freeze would reduce osETH's E-Mode borrowing limit to zero. Existing borrowers could repay or migrate, while withdrawals would depend on the constraints of each position. The proposal lists wstETH, weETH, cbETH and WETH as alternative collateral available in the same E-Mode. Those alternatives would permit collateral swaps without requiring borrowers to repay all WETH debt first.
LlamaRisk's static analysis found that liquidation-threshold reductions of 2% to 5% would expose most collateral in highly leveraged rsETH and osETH loops to liquidation. The osETH category includes other ETH collateral, which limits targeted changes through a common threshold. LlamaRisk instead proposes working with issuers and allowing positions to unwind naturally, with progress reported monthly. Declining exposure would require no additional action.
If migration does not lower exposure, the proposal retains a WETH base-borrow-rate increase as a last resort. The increase could reach 1%, through 0.5% steps applied no more frequently than monthly. Proposed rebates would compensate WETH borrowers who hold neither rsETH nor osETH for the increase. An accompanying reserve-factor change would maintain the supply rate.
Aave V4 offers another approach to allocating risk costs. V4 hubs pool liquidity, while spokes apply local risk settings and limits on liquidity contributions and withdrawals. A User Risk Premium charges borrowers based on the collateral required to secure the debt. Aave's position-conditions documentation illustrates the mechanism with a 50% premium that raises a 5% base rate to 7.5%. Neither the proposal nor the V4 overview specifies an osETH spoke or a numerical premium for osETH.
Borrowers need both a workable migration route and acceptable borrowing terms for an orderly transition. Lenders face the question of whether governance can lower exposure and appropriately price the risk that remains. Governance's decision on Dmitri's separate assessment request and the approved migration terms will determine how that balance applies to osETH.
Aave Proposes Freezing $279M in osETH Unless StakeWise Wins Separate Vote
CryptoSlateShare
Aave risk adviser LlamaRisk proposed freezing new osETH deposits and borrowing on Aave's V3 Core market on November 10, citing on-chain analysis. StakeWise founder Dmitri requested a separate vote to address concerns before another assessment. The freeze would not affect existing positions. LlamaRisk's analysis valued osETH collateral at $279.4 million, supporting $256.6 million in WETH debt. The proposal includes reducing osETH's E-Mode borrowing limit to zero and offering alternative collateral options like wstETH and WETH. If migration fails, a WETH base-borrow-rate increase could be implemented as a last resort. Altcoins to watch may include those affected by this collateral shift.
Source:Show original
Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information.
Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.



