Tolkien understood better than anyone the power of enigma. It permeates everything he published in his lifetime. Sauron, his titular antagonist, is a character who, over the course of three books, the reader never meets, and whose origins remain tantalisingly obscure. He is a shadowy, malignant presence, almost always lurking backstage. So mysterious, in fact, that we barely know whether he even possesses an actual physical form. We certainly never meet him in the flesh. Nowadays, we know Sauron’s backstory in extraordinary detail, but only because of histories published posthumously, painstakingly curated over entire decades by Tolkien’s son. And even with these impeccable histories now available to us, Tolkien never surrendered the mystery to the minutiae. He gave us the great incredible deeds, the bloody betrayals and the earth shattering cataclysms that shaped the early ages of Middle Earth, but rarely troubled himself with the mundane details of everyday existence or the tedious exposition of every character’s motivations. Through his own decades of gorging on world mythology he understood that mythos building derives much of its power not merely from what it reveals, but from what it leaves to the imagination. The unexplained was not an omission to be corrected. It was an ESSENTIAL PART of the magic. Even after the publication of The Return of the King, readers spent nearly two decades debating the origins of mysterious antagonists like Sauron and the Witch-king. The poet W. H. Auden, one of Tolkien’s earliest and most distinguished champions, was still exploring the nature of good and evil in Middle-earth for years after the trilogy was completed. Auden came remarkably close to identifying Sauron’s origins, speculating in 1967 that he, like Morgoth, was a fallen Vala, a divine being from the ancient mythology of Middle-earth. He was tantalisingly close: Sauron was, in fact, a Maia, a lesser order of the same angelic beings. And now the writers of The Rings of Power come along, apparently intent on giving us the Witch-king’s origin story as a fucking sullen emo kid called Theo that’s been moping around sulking and boring us with every single minute of his screen time for 2 seasons, and expect us to like it? I was honestly weeping for joy when his atrocious character butchered the elf (I can’t even remember the elf’s name, he’s been so forgettable), praying he’d stab Galadriel and Celeborn to death too, then turn the knife on himself to spare us one more goddamn fucking awful second of their hideous storylines and finally put an end to this steaming, hideous turd of a show. Tolkien essentially made modern fantasy possible, elevating it from a minor sub genre into an art form. No serious Tolkien scholar thinks the great man would have felt anything but utter repulsion at what they’ve done to his creation. Tolkien understood that mystery was not a gap in his storytelling, it was one of its greatest strengths. These writers have mistaken filling in the gaps for enriching the mythology, when all they’ve really done is absolutely diminish it in a way that defies belief. An absolute abomination.
Lord DurdenShare
Source:Show original
Disclaimer: The information on this page may have been obtained from third parties and does not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of KuCoin. This content is provided for general informational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind, nor shall it be construed as financial or investment advice. KuCoin shall not be liable for any errors or omissions, or for any outcomes resulting from the use of this information.
Investments in digital assets can be risky. Please carefully evaluate the risks of a product and your risk tolerance based on your own financial circumstances. For more information, please refer to our Terms of Use and Risk Disclosure.