Peter Schiff Calls Strategy's $216M BTC Sale a 'Mid-Cycle Ponzi'

Headline: Peter Schiff Labels Strategy a “Mid‑Cycle Ponzi” After $216M BTC Sale — Market Watches for Strain on Bitcoin Peter Schiff doubled down on his criticism of Strategy on July 7, calling the company’s evolving capital model a “mid‑cycle Ponzi” after it sold part of its Bitcoin reserve to fund dividends tied to its Digital Credit securities. What happened - Strategy sold 3,588 BTC for roughly $216 million, a transaction disclosed yesterday that the company said was intended to fund dividend payments on its Digital Credit preferred securities. - After the sale, Strategy reported holdings of 843,775 BTC and $2.55 billion in U.S. dollar reserves. - Strategy remains the largest publicly traded corporate holder of Bitcoin and is closely associated with Michael Saylor’s long‑term accumulation message. Why Schiff is alarmed Schiff argues Strategy has shifted from an original model—raising capital through stock and debt to buy Bitcoin—toward one that increasingly depends on selling Bitcoin to cover interest, dividends, debt costs and buybacks. He warned that this structure could create pressure if Bitcoin prices fall and yields rise, pointing specifically to the STRC preferred shares: a weaker BTC price may force Strategy to boost dividend yields to keep demand for its preferred securities, which Schiff says resembles a Ponzi‑like feedback loop. The company’s new framework - Strategy authorized up to $1.25 billion in Bitcoin sales under its Digital Credit Capital Framework. - Proceeds from that program can be used to support cash reserves, preferred dividends (STRC), debt costs, and buybacks. - Strategy also raised the STRC dividend rate to 12% and set buyback authority for both preferred securities and Class A shares. Saylor’s response and the company’s stated intent Michael Saylor has defended the approach, saying Strategy intends to avoid becoming a net seller of Bitcoin rather than to adopt an absolute “never sell” policy. He has framed future sales as limited and part of broader capital planning, insisting the company’s goal is continued accumulation: “Even if we were to sell one Bitcoin, we’d be buying 10 to 20 more,” he has said. Market reaction and outlook - Bitcoin traded around $63,369 at the latest check, after fluctuating between $61,350 and $64,435 during the session. - Strategy’s stock was trading near $100.77, implying a market cap of about $33.65 billion. Schiff warned that additional BTC sales by Strategy could put pressure on the $58,000 support level and potentially push Bitcoin below $50,000 if the market can’t absorb supply. The market hasn’t validated that worst‑case scenario: crypto.news reported Bitcoin recovered after the 3,588 BTC sale, and Bitwise CEO Hunter Horsley said, “Bitcoin wants to be higher.” Why it matters Strategy’s model ties together large BTC reserves, preferred dividends, share dynamics and market confidence. The key question for traders and investors is whether the market can absorb further monetization under the company’s authorized plan without denting Bitcoin’s price or forcing Strategy into higher yields or more aggressive sales. The next test will be whether demand holds if Strategy continues to monetize portions of its treasury under the Digital Credit program — and whether critics like Schiff are right to warn of structural risks.