Original Title: NYSE and HIP-3 Aren't Competing

Original Author: @HIGH333R, Crypto Creator

Original translation: AididiaoJP, Foresight News

Those simplistic views believe that 24/7 trading is the only value; in fact, the NYSE and HIP-3 even target different user groups.

Someone said: "The NYSE now offers round-the-clock trading, which is a fatal blow to perpetual futures DEXs for all stocks. People previously used Hyperliquid because it allowed 24/7 trading—now that advantage is gone."

This statement is concise, intuitive, and sounds smart, but it's wrong.

The logic is generally like this:

1. People trade stock perpetual contracts on HIP-3 because the U.S. stock market closes at 4 PM.

2. NYSE announces the launch of 7×24 hourly tokenized trading.

3. Therefore, there is no need to use HIP-3 anymore.

4. The perpetual stock DEX is dead.

If 7×24 trading is truly the only value, then the above logic is sound.

But the truth is quite different, far from it. The 24-hour trading is just the easiest point to explain.

What exactly is the NYSE doing?

First, clarify what the NYSE actually announced:

· Tokenized U.S. Stocks and ETFs

· 24/7 Trading

Real-time settlement (as opposed to T+1)

· Deposit and withdraw funds using stablecoins

· Requires regulatory approval

· Launch later this year (possible)

Of course it's important; I didn't say it wasn't.

But it's also important to clarify what the NYSE did not do:

· Not permission-free

· Not globalized

· Not leveraged

· Not composable

· Not self-hosted

These are not minor differences, but fundamental distinctions in the product.

Feature comparison not done by anyone

NYSE Tokenization

· KYC/AML Verification

· May require qualified investor status

· U.S. brokerage account

· Bank account

· Subject to regional regulatory restrictions

HIP-3 Perpetual

· A wallet

It's gone, anyone in the world with an internet connection can use it.

A 22-year-old in Lagos can't open a Schwab account to buy tokenized NVIDIA on the NYSE, but can connect to @markets_xyz in 30 seconds to trade. This isn't a minor difference—it's a completely different market.

NYSE Tokenization

• Subject to Regulation T: initial margin of 50%

· Maximum 2x leverage for stocks

· The same margin rules as in traditional markets

HIP-3 Perpetual

· Up to 20x leverage (varies by market)

· Margin Isolation

· More flexible position sizes

If you have an opinion on Tesla's price and want to use leverage: NYSE tokenized stocks offer you 2x, and HIP-3 offers you 20x.

NYSE Tokenization

· Actual equity interest

· Right to dividends

· Voting rights

· Counterparties: Broker + DTCC + Custodian Bank

HIP-3 Perpetual

· Synthetic price exposure

· No ownership, no dividends

· Pure speculative tool

· Counterparty: Smart Contract

One is a certificate of ownership, and the other is a trading instrument. Saying "NYSE killed HIP-3" is like saying "ETFs killed options"—they are fundamentally different things.

· NYSE: Each security is tokenized individually, with regulatory approval required for each asset category, and it can take several months to even years to list new securities.

· HIP-3: No permission required. Listings can be made with a price source, and trading can begin within hours.

Want to trade pre-IPO SpaceX shares? The Big Tech Seven Index? Crude oil? NVIDIA volatility?

HIP-3 will go live this week, while NYSE still has to wait for a regulatory framework that does not yet exist.

NYSE tokenized stocks are on a private chain, require permission for access, and cannot be composited with other protocols.

The positions in HIP-3 are on-chain native assets, which can:

· When collateral is used for borrowing

· Hedge with other DeFi tools

· Integrate into the revenue strategy

· Programmatic Management

This is important for advanced users who build complex strategies.

· NYSE: "Later this year, pending regulatory approval." It could be as late as the end of 2026 or even 2027, and the SEC's delay might even cause it to fall through.

HIP-3: Launched in October 2025, has processed billions of dollars in trading volume.

One is a press release, and the other is already in operation.

Actually, it's like this:

· NYSE tokenization serves U.S. retail investors—who seek regulated, legally protected, holdings through traditional brokers, with normal leverage ratios, in U.S. equities exposure.

HIP-3 serves global traders who want permissionless, leveraged, self-custodied, composable, and exposure to any asset with a price source.

These are two different types of users with different needs.

The NYSE is not competing for HIP-3's market; it is serving a segment that HIP-3 never intended to target: U.S. retail investors who want equity and compliance.

That global trader seeking 10x leverage exposure to NVIDIA won't open a Schwab account just because the NYSE is open 24/7.

"People use HIP-3 just to drain and invest."

Even if some users are like this, it overlooks several points:

· @tradexyz did $1.3 billion in volume in three weeks

· A genuine need for leveraged, permissionless equity exposure

· Global users who cannot access NYSE will continue to use HIP-3

· Real trading volume has already validated the product-market fit.

Airdrops grab attention, but practicality keeps people around.

The real question

The real question is not "Will the NYSE kill HIP-3?" but rather: "What proportion of the global demand for equity price exposure can be covered by regulated U.S. brokers?"

The answer is: rarely.

Most people in the world can't even get into the NYSE — tokenized or not. KYC requirements, geographic restrictions, banking barriers, accredited investor rules...

HIP-3 serves the rest of the people, and "everyone" represents a massive market.

Ironically

Tommy Shaughnessy put it well: "Solana was originally built to compete with the NYSE, and now the NYSE is competing with Solana's core logic in return."

Read it again. It's not that crypto is copying traditional finance, but that traditional finance is copying crypto.

But Tommy also pointed out: "The NYSE model requires KYC, needs permission, and mainly deals in stocks," which is completely different from the existing crypto model that is "permissionless, global, and allows trading of anything."

Permissionlessness is not a feature that can be added later; it's a design philosophy. Due to regulatory constraints, the NYSE can never achieve permissionlessness. They build walled gardens, while crypto builds open fields.

Finally

The NYSE's move to tokenize stocks is actually a form of recognition—it acknowledges that 24/7, instant settlement, tokenized markets are the future. The world's largest exchange has openly admitted this.

But the NYSE serves a specific, regulated, U.S.-centric market. HIP-3 serves a market the NYSE can never touch—one that is permissionless, global, leveraged, and composable.

On-chain traders don't wait for regulatory approvals, don't open brokerage accounts, and won't accept a 2x leverage cap. They are already trading futures on existing infrastructure.

A simplistic view might consider 7×24 hours as the entirety of value. However, a more thorough analysis reveals that it's only a small part, albeit the most straightforward to explain.

No permission required, globally accessible, leveraged, composable, self-custodied, fast deployment...

These won't disappear because of an announcement from the NYSE. On the contrary, they are even more important now.

This isn't NYSE vs HIP-3; it's walled garden vs open fields.

Original article link

Click to learn about BlockBeats' job openings.

Welcome to join the official Lulin BlockBeats community:

Telegram Subscription Group:https://t.me/theblockbeats

Telegram discussion group:https://t.me/BlockBeats_App

Official Twitter account:https://twitter.com/BlockBeatsAsia